
This might actually be the worst of my analogies.
So when people talk about indigenous wisdom or whatever, I’m like … Okay, maybe someone ten thousand years ago came up with a really good farming technique. That person died ten thousand years ago. Someone now can learn that technique from ten thousand years of unbroken tradition, or they can learn that technique because someone wrote it down in a book, but the point is that they learn it. It seems arbitrary to say that some of the people learning it now are a separate group from other people learning it now.
Someday, you are going to die, and if you have kids, those kids will replace you. If you have kids with a woman who’s considered ethnically Jewish, then sure, a Jew will replace you. But it seems arbitrary to act like Jews will be somehow different from all the other people replacing you. None of them will be like you, and all of them will have different beliefs and values from you. So it feels like the “indigenous wisdom” people and the “Jews will not replace us” people are making the same error of logic.