feotakahari: (Default)
A terrible, terrible analogy.

I have no emotional connection to Harry Potter, so it’s easy for me to dismiss someone who says “my Harry Potter A/B/O fanfic with 50 views on AO3 doesn’t support J.K. Rowling.” I could say “stop writing it anyway” and not feel bad, because I wouldn’t write it. I try to remind myself that they’re actually right, and that even if their fic isn’t “important,” there’s no harm if they keep writing it.

I have no emotional connection to gun collecting, so it’s easy for me to dismiss someone who says “my unloaded gun on a display rack doesn’t kill people” . . .
feotakahari: (Default)

Stealing a post from Spacebattles, because it’s fascinating and I want to spread this knowledge. Grey Rook was complaining about how Planetary Annihilation fanfic always gave the MC powers he didn’t canonically have. SparraNova’s response:

There was only one fic that actually did this straight. And that was the ur-Commander SI, which was just called Commander for some reason. That one did this premise ramrod straight, and got popular doing it because of course it did. People picked up on it because, I assume, beyond the massive mountain of wank, the idea of power growth modeled through an R&D system was a pretty novel and neat idea, and it tickles the brain of a particular type of nerd. Here's the thing that makes the OPness so egregious though: most of the people who picked up on the idea and made their own PA SIs seemingly never actually played the game, and if they did didn't really pay attention to what was and wasn't possible, and as a result just copy-pasted the wack-ass wanked-out version without really thinking about it…
Only to realize that their protagonists were too powerful to tell the stories they wanted to tell. Cue all sorts of shit being done to try to nerf the overpowered munchkins (none of which worked because they did things like go 'no canon units you have to design everything yourself!' instead of actually tracing the root of the problem), and even the authors themselves bemoaning how difficult it was to work around something so overpowered.

Planetary Annihilation wank was so obnoxious that the people who were writing it got sick of it ruining their stories and started trying to work around it.

And I think that's truly a monument to wankery like no other.

... Except maybe Fate/Stay Night

feotakahari: (Default)
I’m reading a fanfic about a time traveler trying over and over across thousands of years to avert the tragedies of the canon timeline. It works pretty well as a metaphor for the thousands of AU fanfics that have been written to try and erase the memory of how bad canon got.

Profile

feotakahari: (Default)
feotakahari

July 2025

S M T W T F S
   12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 1st, 2025 11:47 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios